A leaking shower. The last thing anyone wants when they build a new shower.
Yet I hear the following questions quite often:
- Isn’t cement board waterproof?
- The tile and grout will keep the most of the water out, right?
- My contractor didn’t put any waterproofing in our shower. Will this cause a shower to leak?
- We didn’t know we needed a shower moisture barrier. Should we start over?
What inspired this post? A member of the John Bridge forum asking a simple enough question: Is a moisture barrier required?
He had hired a contractor to install his shower and the contractor said that it wasn’t necessary.
However, more information came out, and photos were posted. Then, it became obvious that he was going to have a leaking shower on his hands. I would encourage you to click the link and skim over the post.
A couple of common myths
This might be news to some but let’s get a couple of things out in the open:
- Cement board is not waterproof
- Hardibacker is not waterproof
- Tile and grout are not waterproof
Tile Backer Board Breakdown: Which one is best for showers?
Cement board will not fall apart when exposed to water. But like a concrete walkway, it can soak up water. It can also dry out and be perfectly fine.
What is a moisture barrier?
A moisture barrier is essentially a waterproof barrier. Its purpose is to keep moisture from getting through the backer board and into the wall. Acceptable forms of waterproof barriers for a shower are:
- 4 mil plastic sheet behind the tile backer board
- liquid waterproofing on the surface of the tile backer board
- a waterproof sheet membrane on the surface of the tile backer board
Shower Waterproofing Crash Course
I have a hard time calling a 4 mil plastic sheet behind backer board a waterproof membrane. Why?
Because you attach this membrane by stapling it to the studs then puncture it further by nailing (or screwing) backer board in front of it.
But it is an acceptable, and minimal, way to keep moisture from getting into a wall cavity.
So here’s where I draw the distinction between a moisture barrier and a waterproofing membrane:
- Waterproofing for vertical walls is a moisture barrier
- Horizontal surfaces, even those that slope, need a waterproofing membrane.
Moisture Barrier vs Waterproofing
Now I’m not the only one that makes a distinction between waterproofing vertical and horizontal surfaces.
Custom Building Products requires two coats of their Redgard liquid waterproofing on all waterproof surfaces.
However, they also have this technical bulletin that says that only one coat is needed on the vertical surfaces of the backer board.
It’s sort of like: All bourbons are whiskey but not all whiskey is bourbon. Waterproofing can serve as a moisture barrier but a moisture barrier doesn’t necessarily qualify as a waterproofing barrier.
A moisture barrier is all you need to keep water out of the water cavity. Although you will need more extensive waterproofing for the horizontal surfaces if you want to prevent a shower from leaking.
Where you are likely to have a shower leak
The horizontal surfaces in a shower usually include the shower floor, half walls, benches, curbs, and recessed niches.
Further, these need special attention to ensure that they don’t contribute to a leaking shower.
Acceptable ways of waterproofing these types of surfaces are:
- 2 coats of liquid waterproofing
- waterproof sheet membranes
- Waterproof foam backer board
Additionally, they make fully waterproof foam shampoo niches, corner benches, floating benches, curbs, and shower pans.
Flood testing a shower pan: Why it’s done and how to do it
Here’s the Point
The whole point of this post is to get to this bottom line:
Water containment on shower walls is important and a requirement.
Waterproofing on horizontal surfaces is absolutely critical.
So, if your shower doesn’t have a moisture barrier failure isn’t necessarily imminent. Although I definitely wouldn’t consider it to be a well-built shower.
However, if your horizontal surfaces in the shower aren’t waterproofed a leaking shower is nearly guaranteed!
My shower has a regular sheetrock ceiling, which developed black mold. I washed it with a mixture of vinegar and borax, which cleaned the surface but left a stain. Can I tile over this to prevent future mold? Or do I have to replace the sheetrock with backerboard?
You shouldn’t have any issues sticking the tile to the sheetrock on the ceiling.
In simple terms please. Redoing bathroom. Shower/tub alcove is cement board duralok. Behind cement board I put plastic what next. On other wall do I need plastic first then cement board. Now do I need to do more on walls with tiling half up not near shower. Also floor. Redid subfloor what goes on before cement board thin set and tiles.
I’m having a hard time understanding what’s being asked. Please check your questions and ask again.
I am putting tile down in my kitchen and will be putting Durock and tile in the dishwasher alcove. The alcove is part of the center island that has the sink as well. The subfloor is exposed next to the alcove. My concern is that if the dishwasher should ever develop a leak and water gets out, or the sink over-flows, etc… if water gets in the alcove and thus to the exposed Durcok, will this cause a warping or mold issue with the Durock and subfloor? Should we put a liquid water barrier like Redgard down on the Durock and sub-floor before the tile is applied and the dishwater reinstalled? Thanks for the input.
It certainly wouldn’t hurt but it’s only effective as long as water is contained in the area of the dishwasher. So it’s very likely that water would simply run off of the waterproofed area unless more of the floor is waterproofed and it’s flashed up any vertical surfaces.
Can green board be used anywhere inside shower area including ceiling?
You can use it on the ceiling.
I am remodeling an old house and am in the middle of re-doing the master bathroom shower. The original mud deck and mortar layer on walls are over chicken wire but I doubt it has any moisture barrier or waterproofing layer. I have removed the old tiles and want to install new large tiles with CBP LFT modified mortar. I would like to use RedGuard over the original mortar bed and wall layer to provide an improvement to what is currently there. Do you see any issues with this strategy?
For whatever reason, I’m reluctant to say that it’s OK but I can’t think of a reason that it wouldn’t be. The walls can be coated with Redgard but I wouldn’t put any on the shower pan.
The shower pan is either waterproof right now, or it’s not. There’s no way to tie Redgard into the drain with the way the old shower drains are designed so covering the pan with Redgard doesn’t fix anything. If anything, it can have an adverse effect by trapping moisture between the two waterproofing layers- the layer below the mud bed and Redgard above. But doing the walls is a good plan, I think.
One word of caution: the old mud beds were usually hot mopped or maybe it has a copper or lead shower pan. It’s not unusual at all for those to be compromised at this point in their life. So the best course of action would be to remove and start over.
Hello.I recently renovated my kids shower/tub and only did one coat of Redgard on the vertical walls above the tub.Will this be enough or will I have an issue?
It’s more about thickness than coats but for something like that I think you’ll be ok.
Hey Tile Guy,
Noon question—I recently finished building a tile shower floor and foolishly did not first lay a barrier. Is there anything I can use after the fact to seal it up? Anything like caulking the grout lines helpful? ?
If you don’t have a waterproof membrane in the shower then the best thing is to start over. All that caulking the gaps would do is slow down a leak and when it comes to water damage the slow leaks do the most damage.
Hello Tile Guy,
First, many thanks for all the time you put into your very helpful website. I’ve learned lots and my home renovation projects are better for it.
Second, our contractor agreed to prep a new walk-in shower (I will be doing tile and finish plumbing). The space was formerly a tub/shower combination. Contractor did a presloped pan, plumber did rough plumbing and rubber membrane, then contractor finished the pan, installed a curb, and hung Denshield, taping the abutting joints.
My concern is: his installation of the Densheild doesn’t look much like the manufacturer’s diagram I’ve since seen. In my shower, the Denshield comes down to meet the horizontal plane of the sloping floor base (withing 1/8″). In the Densheild diagram, they show the sides of the pan as an elevated rim around the perimeter (similar to the height of the curb). The diagram shows how this rim elevates the bottom edge of the Densield a couple inches above the horizontal plane of the floor. This isn’t what I have to work with and I’m concerned about longevity of the backing material.
I know Densield is less prone to wicking and I know I can/should seal the small gap at the bottom of the backer boards, but I’m hoping I can add an insurance policy. I’m using redgaurd with a crack isolating fabric to fully waterproof the curb and areas more prone to leaks like the windowsill (vinyl window). Could I use this same method where the Denshield meets the floor?
In my opinion, Denshield is a pretty minimal product, quality-wise, to have in a shower like this. Consequently, now there’s a sort of “belt & suspenders” fix so that everyone feels better about things.
Here’s the main issue: the shower pan method that was used is designed to work in a certain way. Trying to patch things up with more waterproofing, although it sounds advisable, can actually be counter-productive and trap water in.
Water will get into the mud bed (top layer) and then travel so that it’s underneath the corner that you are wanting to install the waterproofing. Same thing with the shower curb (hopefully your contractor didn’t screw Denshield onto the curb). As you can see, waterproofing these corners isn’t going to accomplish what you want.
So, at this stage, the shower pan either works or it doesn’t. If it doesn’t work, then it needs to be torn out, or repaired, until it functions properly. Hopefully, a water-test was done on the shower liner to make sure that it doesn’t leak. But I don’t recommend a band-aid approach to the shower at this point.
With that being said, the Denshield needs to be waterproofed at all seams and penetrations and I would definitely use the Redgard waterproofing fabric around the window.
Hello Tile Guy,
After my contractor finished and left I realized he did a couple things wrong with the shower:
1) the pan was sloped however after I turned on the shower I realize there is a low spot that collects water. I can just sweep the water up and into the drain, so this is more of an annoyance, but so you see a major issue with this? I’ve contemplated having just the area tiles ripped out, slope corrected, and tiles reinstalled. I think this might work bc the waterproofing is redgard uncoupling mat which probably wouldn’t rip (more concerning question on redgard mat below).
2) more concerning issue. My contractor used redgard uncoupling mat. It’s the thicker “waterproof” barrier fabric. After I did some research (after this was finished of course), I realized this is meant for general tile floors or even shower walls, but not the shower floor. It’s clearly too late to do anything about it. The material is waterproof after all. Do you think I am doomed to have a failure/ leak/ mold? We have small hex marble tiles. I’ve applied two coats of floor sealer and all seams are caulked. Would of course prefer to not have to have the floor ripped up as it is expensive tile, our contractor is from out of town and not coming back, and based on labor costs in my area ripping out the floor and doing it again would be a couple thousand.
I would definietly fix the corner and hopefully it won’t hurt the waterproofing below. But by repairing the tiles in the corner you can see how the corners of the waterproofing were done.
One of the things about the uncoupling membrane is that it’s dimpled and that would provide a little bit of an impediment to attaching waterproof seam tape to it and running it up the wall. I’m assuming that’s how it would be done- the mat on the floor and seam tape folded in the corners.
I’m not saying it couldn’t be done but it would have to be fussed over a little bit during the installation.
Hopefully, everything with the shower is waterproofed OK and there’s nothing to worry about.
Thanks for the reply! That is somewhat a relief, about the uncoupling membrane being usable. The spot that isn’t sloped properly/ puddles is actually in the middle of the shower floor near the side of the shower step (the drain is all the way on the right side). So if we popped those tiles out and built up the floor it would not affect the seam, but would be just the uncoupling membrane may only. I’m thinking the membrane would be fine if we popped those tiles.
Also, unfortunately I already have a leak. The grout on the shower curb has cracked and water seems to have gotten behind the tile and around to the side of the step of the bathroom floor. Water leaks out of the bottom of the curb at the bottom of a grout joint. At this point I’m thinking we’re going to have to completely redo the step, and some of the shower floor tile, as a best case scenario. Re-grouting and caulk would just be a bandaid. Our originally contractor just used pressure treated wood for the step with no waterproofing. I wish I had been more educated while he was doing this but now I know. He made some major mistakes.
That is unfortunate but at least you have caught it before it does major damage. As an FYI, you don’t want to use pressure treated wood in a shower. It seems like a good idea on the surface but what happens is it dries out and twists. Normal wood is the way to go.
You might look for a contractor that has taken training from one of the companies that sells a complete shower system. Laticrete, Wedi, and Schluter are probably the three most popular names.
As a rule of thumb, the shower should be waterproof before tile is installed. You never rely on tile and grout to keep water out.
Water proofing is a relatively new concept for shower walls. I’ve tiled probably well over 1000 showers in my 20+ years of setting tile directly over backer board and to my knowledge never had a problem. STANDING water is the problem, water cannot stand on vertical walls. I’ve tiled around a dozen family members and relatives showers, many of whom still live in the same homes decades later and noon of them have developed leaks or water damage that I’m aware of. I’ve tiled 5 showers in my own two homes over the last 20 years (my best friend bought my first home and the old tile showers are still in tact), never using anything but cement board and all showers are still leak free. HardieBoard does NOT recommend a vapor barrier behind their product in showers. Shower pans are the only areas that NEED waterproofing. If it makes you feel better to apply waterproofing membrane to the whole shower.. be my guest, I do it all the time for customers, but it’s a big waste of money in material and labor. I just ripped out a 60 year old shower recently, which had nothing but mortar and lathe on the walls and everything was a dry as a bone. The whole shower waterproofing membrane industry is questionable. A solution looking for a problem. At least when it comes to walls, which of course takes up most of the budget for “waterproofing”.
I also am a 20+ year tile setter and have no idea of how many showers that I’ve built. The earlier ones didn’t have a waterproofing barrier.
Not using a waterproof barrier doesn’t guarantee failure. I can point instances where tile that was installed over drywall that lasted 30 years. I can also point to showers that didn’t last 10 years.
You’re welcome to build showers how you like but we know better now and there are better products now than what existed in the 80’s and 90’s. Why one wouldn’t take advantage of these products is a mystery to me.
Question
I have installed Hardieback 500 on the walls and purchased Redgard and about ready to apply but have been reading most people use wonderboard with this product. If I use the diluted Redgard for first application is my Hardieback ok to use?
You don’t have to use cement board. The diluted Redgard should be fine as a primer coat.
Question along these lines – our contractor has installed Go Board and a prefabricated shower pan and covered everything with a green water proof material. So far so good. Now the shower wall tile is being installed. We are using the larger 32” x 12” tiles. They are not covering the entire wall with mud or thin set. Rather the mud / thin set is applied where the corner of the tile meet and spacers are needed. This is leaving an air gap behind the tile. I am concerned that if the grout cracks in the future moisture and mold will find a home behind the tile. Should I be concerned?
It sounds like what we refer to as a ”5 dot” installation which is not approved. Additionally, the number of “dots” of thinset are irrelevant.
Basically, industry standards require 95% mortar coverage in wet areas and it doesn’t sound like that’s what you are getting.
So, yes, you should be concerned and the contractor needs to do better.
I am renovating my tub into a tiled shower unit with a dreamline shower base. My plan is to use hardie backer board and redgard. Here are my questions:
1. Should the hardie backer lip over the tile flange and if so how much?
2. I will mortar and tape all joints but should I also apply a mesh with the redgard?
3. What extra precautions should I take to waterproof my niche? Niche will be built on site with hardie backer
Thank you
The Hardibacker should extend past the tub lip. How much doesn’t really matter however you should check with the manufacturer and see if they have a guideline on this. It’s something that’s a little bit hard to control because you are using an existing framed space usually.
You don’t need to add any additional mesh with Redgard. For your niche, you might find this post helpful:
Building a Completely Custom Shower Niche from Scratch | DIYTileGuy
I have a moisture barrier on the outside facing walls with insulation. The heavy plastic is covering the insulation and studs and my mild resistant green drywall is on top of that. My contractor said he was going to mud everything and use an oil based kilz primer to seal it, essentially making it waterproof – I found nothing about this technique while researching waterproofing a bathroom. I made him buy the redguard and we’re using this on the entire bathroom floor and in the shower over the green mold resistant drywall and around the build drop in for the tub. Truly I’m debating taking off the drywall and replacing it with duralock or whatever backer board is required for waterproofing. So my question is will it be worth it or just a waste of time? Would the redguard work over the green drywall and then we tile directly on to the redguard? Or should I take off the drywall replace with the cement board and waterproof that and then tile? And if I use cement board can I use redguard to waterproof it or should I be looking at something else?
Another question I’m having is waterproofing the entire bathroom floor. The subfloor is replaced. And redguarded I was thinking of placing concrete leveler and then laying my vinyl plank flooring on top. Is this even necessary?
It sounds like there are several different methods and products being considered but they don’t all work together.
It sounds like the contractor was going to do a one-step mud method which is acceptable if done correctly. You don’t want to redgard over drywall and stick tile to the redgard.
You can Kerdi over drywall but usually it’s best to remove the drywall and install a tile backer board.
I don’t know a lot about lvt. Be careful which self levelers that you install over wood subfloors
I have spent so much time, energy and money to fully tear apart and rebuild a shower because the previous owners used this “five dot” method of installing all the tiles. I think they re-tiled an old shower as quickly as possible in order to sell the home.
After 3 or 4 months of regular use, the tiles started literally falling off the walls. A very dangerous situation, when children were taking showers and had 4″ x 4″ ceramic tiles falling on their heads and shattering when they hit the floor. I can’t imagine the damage that could be done to someone in the shower if one of those 32″ x 12″ tiles fell on someone’s head. I hope you were able to stop and make them redo the job correctly.
Do NOT under any circumstances ever let anyone use that method to tile in a shower.
Again, thanks for your comments. Real feedback is important and helpful to others.
Hi!
I stumbled upon your website while looking for tile setting tips and tricks so we can tackle a bathtub surround remodel!
I just want to be sure I’m understanding of the proper methods to ensure a successful project so that we aren’t redoing this in the next 10 years.
1. Install 4mil plastic to studs of walls. All walls above the bathtub? Do we put the plastic behind the tub or let it over hang the lip a bit?
2. Cement board. Do we touch the cement board to the lip of the tub or leave a gap?
3. Red guard all the seams and screws or do we redguard the over all the cement board?
4. Mortar and set tiles.
5. Grout.
6. Seal grout.
7. Caulk edge of tub and corners.
Am I missing anything? Any other tips?
Thanks!
You’ve got it basically right but I wouldn’t install the plastic over the studs unless there is some sort of reason to. The Redgard on the surface would be a better way.
Make sure that you thinset the seams and corners of the cement board with mortar and alkaline mesh tape. Then, once that’s dry, apply the redgard over the complete surface- thicker than you would think. It should be nearly “driver’s license” thick.
Typically, I keep the cement board above the flange of the tub but it can depend on the tub. The best tip I can give you is to flatten your walls prior to installing the cement board.
Good luck!
Perfect! Tha k you!
I ask about the plastic because 1 of our 3 shower walls is an exterior wall with insulation? Does that give us a reason to do so?
You don’t need the plastic for the shower if you use Redgard. You’ll have to make a determination on what you need for your insulation and house wrap. That’s beyond my tile niche of information.
Hi
I am in the process of finishing my basement. The contractor installed cement board in the tub surround but the tile guy didn’t redguard. Just tiled to the cement board, should this be redone?
It should be waterproofed but, if it’s not, it doesn’t mean that failure is imminent. But if they cut any other corners then it could be a big problem.
So you’ll have to figure out the course of action that you want to take. Waterproofing is an industry standard. You may elect to have the contractor extend their warranty, discount the price, etc. There’s no one way to handle it from here.
Hi,
Thanks for the article, I read every single question and answer. It’s an emergency here, we are in the middle of remodeling our master bathroom, my contractor just finished the installation of cement board. And he is going to put mortar and tile on the shower wall directly, which I disagreed with. I actually bought the aquadefene as suggested by Lowe’s to waterproof the shower wall, but he refused to do so because he think the cement board is waterproofing. And he always says he has done this for dozens of household, I am the first one to ask him to do this. For the shower floor he did put the shower pan liner above the cement board.
So my questions are: 1. Do I need to put the aquadefense all over the shower wall or just the corner/ seam/ nail hole?
2, how to apply the aquadefense? Just paint over the cement board? Or apply the thinset mortar first then 2 coats of aquadefense then mortar/tile.
3, will the aquadefense affect the tile setting? My contractor said it will weaken the attachment of the tile to mortar.
4. For the shower floor is the shower pan liner enough to waterproof? Do I need to apply aquadefense additionally?
5. Do I need to waterproof the rest of my bathroom floor? I mean other than shower floor.
I will appreciate your answer and help. Thank you very much.
Hello. I am redoing a small bathroom. The only bathroom in the house–about 30 square feet of floor space. The tub and toilet are about 2 feet apart. The shower has no shower doors on it anymore and the bathroom floor has had some water abuse. Vinyl tile was used with plywood. I am now redoing it and finding wet wood underneath the vinyl tile. The toilet needs to stay functional as much as possible. I have removed 2 square feet of wet plywood and discovered mold on the subfloor. What do I do at this point? Use some type of mold treatment and reinforce the subfloor by sistering up the joists or do I replace the subfloor at the affected sections and then build back up? What do I use instead of regular plywood? Do I use Kilz stain or something else? What flooring is best for this application(while remaining somewhat economical, not high end stuff)? Can I keep the vinyl flooring on the dry parts of the bathroom and mix the flooring up a bit? Thank you very much because these answers will get a long ways to completion and doing it the right way at the same time!
You should apply Aquadefense over the top of the cement board. First, the seams should be taped and thinset over and the screwheads should be filled flat. Then two (or three?) coats Aquadefense over everything with dry times between each coat.
Don’t apply it over the mud bed- just the cement board. You can put it over the rest of your floor if you want or maybe just immediately outside the wet area also. Neither of those places is required.
The waterproofing membrane may weaken the bond a bit but, if the contractor is using the right mortar, the bond will be plenty adequate.
You’ll want to take care of the mold. I’ve seen a product called Concobrium at Home Depot. I’ve used that for minor things before and you may need to look into remediation if it’s bad enough.
Once the mold is taken care of then you’ll need to assess if the subfloor is sound. Does it need to be replaced in spots? Maybe completely?. Same for the joist structure.
For the subfloor, you need 5/8 inch minimum exterior grade plywood over the joists for a tile installation. You can replace the plywood in stages if you want if that makes things easier for you. The seams and edges all need to be supported.
I recently did a bathroom renovation and the contractor did not use any redguard or waterproofing on the vertical surfaces of the shower. So, the walls were built up as durock on wood studs, mudded and then tiled. The tile is ceramic hex mosaic tile on one wall and slate on the two other walls. There is a window with a horizontal shelf. This was painted with at least one coat of redguard on the sill and the side jambs of the window (wrapping around the corners about 4″). The water proofing of the floor is just a rubber pan beneath the topping slab and tile.
Should I be worried that the vertical surfaces of the walls are not water proofed? My worry is that the wall grout and especially slate tile is quite porous. So, the walls will become damp over time.
It’s not ideal but I don’t think it’s something to panic over. I’d keep up on the sealing of the slate tiles as those are pretty porous tiles.
Hi Tile Guy,
Quick question for you. I hired a contractor to install an American Bath Factory shower kit only to be left in a mess and a lot of wasted money.
It seems the contractor had not taken any steps at waterproofing the vertical portion of shower, he did not use any kind of membrane and had not taken any care to tape or seal the seams.
Fortunately, he cut the pre-sized wall panels to the point where there are large gaps where the pieces should butt up to each other making his mistakes easily visible. (gaps from 1/8 to over 1/2 inches due to some wavy cuts)
Frayed material from the cement board was clearly visible through the gaps and the wood studs could be seen in looking closer.
I did hire another contractor to come in to install a tile shower. All is well at this point. However, I’m hoping you can answer a few things for me.
In your experience, was the initial install as bad as it sounds? The first contractor had told me to just grout the corners and everything would be fine.
Is it common practice to skip the taping or sealing the seams?
Would grout do anything to keep the water from entering in through the corners?
I really don’t know on this because the product that is being installed isn’t tile. You’re installing panels and they would have different guidelines. It’d be best to ask someone with experience with this type of shower.
Hello and best regards from Serbia,
I just stumbled upon Your article and realised that Your opinion might be of an immense help to me, for which I’d be very thankful.
Well, I’m working on a bathroom where the cement floor screed is made nearly a week ago. Water pipes are placed and it’s all patched with the mixture of grit sand, cement and a bit of the whitening lime. It’s drying nicely despite the cold period of the year. I’m about to put tiles on both, the floor and the walls up to the ceiling. SomeIItalian grouting compound that I bought says to have an aqua-resistant property (will choose 2mm width for the wall and 3mm for the floor). There’s going to be an acrylic bathtub with side panels, but also the shower head high on the wall so it’s also used as a shower tub. The floor do have a nice slope towards the drain in the middle of the bathroom. In other corner will be the toilet, there’s also a wash basin, and in some time will place the washing machine.
So, now should get in touch with the tiler and schedule the tiling but his opinion on whether or not to apply that liquid elastic hydro isolation (applied by the brush in two coats) isn’t clear. And my choice will further influence what glue to buy for tiling. That’s why I’m here. The water insulating liquid is quite pricey for me and I’m thinking whether do I really need it hence there’s going to be a bathtub (not a tile shower), and that (to be tiled) corner of the wall where the shower will be splashed by the water, I’d surely wipe after each use. So, do I really need to spend extra money on those one or two-component hydro isolating liquids? In the case that it’s still the must, should I then be required to apply it on both the surfaces, the walls and the floor, or just on the part of the walls that are going to be in touch with the water. By the way, the house is a one floor one so there’s no one living below, instead of the worms deep down in the ground. :)
Thank you very much for your time to consider my dilemma.
Here in the USA, the only time you need to have waterproofing is when it’s inside an area that is going to get really wet- like a shower. It’s expected that outside the shower could get wet but waterproofing isn’t required in that situation.
If I understand your situation correctly, you could use the liquid waterproofing on the walls but using something like plastic behind the walls would work too.
Good luck on this project and it makes me happy that my blog can be of benefit to someone as far away as Serbia.
I live on the second floor of a concrete building. My boyfriend redid my bathroom with hardy board and 2 coats of redguard and then tiled it. He never used a membrane of rubber or plastic and no shower pan. He claims with red guard we dont need it. I am worried it will leak and my downstairs neighbors will sue ! Help can I stop worrying????
What are your thoughts on Diamonback Board vs HardieBacker or Durock. Planning to use RedGard or Auqa Defense regardless. I also built a niche the length of the wall. Should i use Kerdi on the entire niche area or is Kerdi Tape on the corners of niche and two coats of waterproofing sufficient? Thanks for your advice.
It depends on how the shower floor was waterproofed and if it tied into the drain properly. I have no way of knowing how well it was done.
I’ve seen Diamond board in photos but I don’t know much about it. It appears to be in the same category as Denshield. If this is the case, I would Kerdi the whole niche and around the outside of it.
We recently had our bathroom remodeled. They used Fusion Pro as grout. It did ok on the walls but failed on the floor. It was chalky and had pin holes and areas of grout coming out. They took it all out and wanted to use Fusion again even though we weren’t too excited about that. They had to add more slope also as water was pooling so they pulled out a section of tile. It was a 12 inch by 12 of 2×2 by one side of the drain. They put a new sheet in and not sure what they used to adhere and after a couple of hours regrouted with Fusion. The replaces square all did strange things with the grout and was a different color. My guess is too wet underneath. The rest of the shower floor was much lighter and chalky on top. Update, removed all of the grout again. He used a razor blade and some other manual tools. I can tell the red guard membrane underneath has been cut in a few places. It also had a Kerri liner under that and I can also see in one place it has been cut also. He regrouted with Prism on Friday and there is still a lot of grout on top so is coming back Monday to remove the rest. Are we screwed now that our waterproof membrane has obviously been perforated on a number of places. We don’t know what to do. This is the second replacement now of the shower floor .
Update, this is actually the third shower floor since they have taken the fusion out twice now. Saturday was Prism grout day. Finished in afternoon. Came today (Monday) and watered down the entire shower floor with hand held shower head and removed haze. Told me to water it two more times today and then tomorrow morning. Not what the package said.
If the primary membrane is on top, directly underneath the tile, and it’s been pierced or punctured then your shower is going to leak. I’d want them to prove that they didn’t puncture it. Maybe they remove all of the tiles and retest it with water?
Prism is a good grout. I’d be more concerned about the shower holding water than I would with discoloration. Prism does quite well with being color consistant.
Hello,
I recently had a home built and the shower does not appear to have been waterproofed. The contractor has assured us that it was but said that we could take off a single tile to prove that. He has since come back and said that if we remove the tile the waterproofing behind it will be compromised. Is there a way to tell without removing tile?
If he waterproofed the surface that is immediately behind the tile then it probably will compromise the waterproofing. You could try to remove the shower faucet trim and see if you can see waterproofing behind there. That may be a way to check.
We are building a bathroom and installing a shower. For the shower pan the contractor put down a PVC liner, then covered that with Quik Rite Mortor. He let that dry. Then used SimpleSet Pre-Mixed Thinset on top of the mortor and installed the floor tile. He did not waterproof the pan. Then he put in the durock board on the walls. The floor tile goes under the walls. Walls do not touch the tile. The curb at this time only has the liner wrapped over it. When the curb gets covered with durock board, the board will be over some of the tile. First, is the liner under the Quik Rite sufficient to waterproof the pan? Second, when the durock walls get taped and mudded can I use the tape and mud to close the gaps between the wall and floor covering a little of the tile? Then can I use Red Gard over the dried mud between the wall and the floor? Or, do I need to remove the tile and use Red Gard to waterproof the floor?
If this contractor used simple set pre-mixed adhesive on the shower floor it makes me question every step he’s done.
For starters, having a liner under the mortar bed is a perfectly fine way of waterproofing the shower. It should have a flood test done on it to check for leaks but there shouldn’t be any additional waterproofing on the top. Additionally, I’m not a fan of how he did the Durock board but I can’t say that there is technically anything wrong with it.
Installing Durock over the curb, however, is an issue. Once the liner wraps over the curb there shouldn’t be any penetrations to the liner unless it’s on the front, outside part of the curb. What was supposed to be done was to embed some reinforcing diamond lath (think chicken wire) into the mud bed and wrap it over the curb. But that wasn’t done and I don’t see a way to do it now without removing the mortar bed.
Hopefully, your liner completely covers the corners and all exposed wood on the curb when it wraps over. They make preformed corners that go on each end because that is a likely spot to leak if it’s not don’t correctly.
Finally, just to be clear Simple Set mortar shouldn’t be used for a shower floor. It’s right in the datasheet for the product.
I am purchasing a rental house that has a second bathroom with a large jetted tub but the walls are just plain drywall and painted the same color as the bathroom. There is a shower head installed but I believe the residents just used it as a tub to bathe their kids as the upstairs bathroom has a shower as well. What are my options for making this into a usable shower as far as waterproofing the walls? I suppose I could just install a D-shaped shower curtain rod (like the ones they make for claw foot tubs) as a temporary solution but could I redguard the walls as is and then tile over them in the future? Thanks!
What it depends on is if the walls come down directly on the tub, or not. If the tub is sitting in a wood platform then the walls probably wouldn’t work to use it as a shower. You have to think about how the water would drain when it’s on the walls. Would water run down the walls and be able to find it’s way to the drain?
If the walls come down and sit on top of the tub then there’s probably a way to make it work. The curtain that you are talking about would definitely work.
Hi diytileguy!
Contractor tore out old tub, custom framed walk in shower, poured cement pre-slope pan, put in membrane (inside) cement board. Said, ok, ready to tile! (Our deal was he would get it tile ready, I’m a novice at everything. So I went to the store and bought what they told me to buy…) Well, the drain was too high for the thinset and tile. So my family built it up, using versa bond LFT. (The store…) Well, of course it’s uneven and has cracks. So I called the technical number on the bag of versa bond (the guy, Gabe, sounded surprised to talk to a homeowner that used Versa Bond LFT on a membrane. Of course, he told me it won’t bond to the membrane). I called because I didn’t know what was wrong, why was it uneven and cracked, of course we used the wrong stuff. Should have used something to dry pack the floor and then tile. And that’s not Versa Bond LFT. So here’s the big Q: All these mistakes. I can just take out the Versa Bond floor and start over above the membrane. However, a downstairs shower that won’t get a lot of use most of the year…what is the most likely scenario if I just add another thin layer of Versa Bond LFT (evenly) and then set the mosiac tile on it? Thanks!
Hi Karla, I need a few more details about your situation. It sounds like your contractor built a traditional shower where the liner goes inside the mud pan. Does that sound right? I refer to a traditional shower in this post so see if that looks like the right one.
Did the contractor expect you to install tile directly on top of the liner? Or is there an additional mud layer on top of the liner that you were to install tile over?
Have you ever heard of using 30# felt roofing paper instead of 4 mil plastic between backer board and studs? I’m doing a small 32″x32″ shower stall with a pan. Felt paper would go over all studs and down over the lip of the nailer edging of the pan .. Then backer board just a little lower to about a 1/4″ above the finished ledge of the pan. Does this sound OK to you?
Joints for backer board would be covered with mesh tape and skim coated prior to tiling.
Thank you!
Yes, that works just fine.
Eddie, do you use moisture barrier at all on the shower wall if it is adjacent to an interior wall closet on other side? Do you use moisture barrier of sheer wall is adjacent to an exterior wall?
Hi there, our tiled shower has some grout missing. I’m worried about leakage as it’s upstairs. A tiler came to inspect yesterday but can’t re-grout until next week. Will a waterproof tape be suitable to cover the areas of concern until the tiler can come? I wouldn’t want it to damage tiles when being pulled off? thanks!
It’s hard to say. If your shower is built the way that it should be then missing grout won’t have any effect on the shower’s waterproofing. However, many showers are not built properly and sometimes missing grout can speed up a leak.
But waterproofing tape would probably work in a pinch if it’s your only shower. I would let it dry out for 24 hours prior to the regrouting.
Fixing Shower After Membrane Installed Improperly:
Will you please provide advice.
Shower Size: 4’x9’
What has been already performed:
1. The flooring was removed
2. Beams were reinforced
3. Plywood laid on the floor
Is there anything you would recommend to ensure this will never happen again outside of what is listed below (pending quality workmanship)?
1. Remove one or two rows of 18×18 tiles (ordered enough tile for two rows)
2. Install membrane
3. Lay tile
*Should I have a cement layer installed under the plywood?
*Should I have a mold barrier sprayed?
Thank you incredibly for your advice!! ☺️
It sounds like you are wanting to repair the waterproof membrane by only removing the lower part of the shower. If so, it should be only necessary to remove one 18×18 at the bottom of the shower.
What you need to do is leave about 1 inch of the backer board that is hanging lower than the second row of tile. That way, you can reinstall new backer board and you have 1 inch to apply mesh tape and tie the two backer boards together.
What I don’t know is what type of shower you are building. Is it a traditional shower with a liner under the mortar? Is it one of the newer showers like a Kerdi shower?
This is important. Assuming that it is a traditional shower, you will need a cement layer underneath the liner that slopes to the drain. Then you would install another cement layer that is a minimum of 1.5 inches thick.
Make sure that you are also redoing the curb.
https://www.diytileguy.com/shower-waterproofing/
My dad’s 1956 house has three tiled shower stalls. a handyman refinished one of the showers by rebuilding the floor with correctly sloped mud and membrane. He removed the pink tile about four feet up and put in white tile. It looks nice and does not leak, but I am concerned that he did not put any moisture barrier all the way up all four vertical sides of the shower. Is a membrane required all the way up?
He also started to rebuild the downstairs shower, which had a leak, but after tearing out the 4×4 tiles he wasn’t able to finish. We need to have the shower working, so we will hire someone else. should we have them tear out all the tiles and install redguard or a membrane all the way up, or leave it with moisture barrier 4 feet up the vertical sides?
When doing a repair, there are, undoubtedly, going to be some compromises involved. Assuming this person repaired the one shower properly he probably has a liner installed under the floor tile and this would fold up the sides and be behind the backer board.
It’s always nice if he can install a waterproofing layer on the walls as high as he can but if the existing shower didn’t have a waterproofing layer on the walls anything that he puts on is going to have limits to its effectiveness.
Hi,
We recently remodeled our bathroom. Our contractor used green board everywhere, including the shower area! Foolishly, we tiled over the green board not knowing better as the contractor said that was fine. It’s all grouted and tiled now… shower is installed (we used 3×6 subway tile with 1/8 inch grout lines). Now I’m freaking out knowing we should have used a membrane before laying tile. Can we do anything to the tile and grout after the fact? We bought high quality grout/tile sealer already.
Sealer certainly won’t hurt anything and will help in a very small way. The best thing to do is just to keep an eye on things and make sure everything is sealed up. You should have a 100% silicone sealant in the corners and around the plumbing trim pieces. Make sure the grout holes are filled.
The danger comes when water gets past the tile. You want to make sure that happens as little as possible.
Hi. Did our shower about 4 years ago and realized we never used waterproofing over the hardie board. We are having moisture issues with the groutline along the edge of our bathtub. We have had to keep applying and removing caulk because it gets moldy and gross looking after a few months on this line where the tile meets the tub. Today I pulled the caulk off and some of the grout came with it and was crumbling and wet. So if moisture keeps getting stuck along that area, what is the solution? Since it only happens along the bottom grout line, (closest to the spout I might add) do we REALLY have to tear out the whole thing and start over or would it be possible to just remove the lower tiles along the tub and waterproof, then re-lay tiles? I’m so heartbroken over this mistake, I appreciate your advice..Thanks!
If you have a tub then the likelihood of water damage problems is reduced compared to a shower. There are two things here: water getting behind the tile and the caulk getting moldy.
First off, do your best to figure out why water is getting behind the tile. Make sure your faucet trim is caulked to the tile (usually clear silicone). Make sure there are no holes in the grout that are allowing water a free way in. Next, some tubs have a weep system on them and, if your tub has something then you want to make sure that it’s not grouted, caulked, or sealed up.
A weep system is simply an indentation in the tub. They look like this (second photo down) and are on the side walls right before the rim of the tub that you step over.
Not all tubs have them and if yours doesn’t then don’t worry about it.
Next, remove all the silicone around the perimeter of the tub, clean it off really well, and let it sit and dry out for a couple of days, if possible.
Then recaulk with 100% silicone using this technique in this video.
You may find that the silicone will attract dirt over time but you will be able to clean any dirt and mildew off of it. It won’t become part of the caulking.
Thank you! I am going to open up the access panel in the closet behind the shower to see if I can find any answers. Also, I watched your caulking video. There are no weeps from what I could tell. Should I remove the grout from the tub line to install the backer rod and apply caulk or is that grout necessary?
I would caulk it but I suppose you could leave it open if you wanted.
Hi Tile Guy ! I have a similar question about “the plastic” and redgard… i’m working on my bathtub walls and already installed the cement boards.. and my plan was to use regard but I installed the plastic barrier behind the boards (just up to 4’) before finding out that I can’t do both… so do you think it would be an issue if I use regard for corners and seams ? Like i said, i just installed the plastic barrier up to 4’ above the flange..
The plastic should go up a little higher but I probably wouldn’t worry about Regdard unless you want to put it on from about 3.5 ft to 6 or 7 ft high. That way it overlaps the plastic.
Keep in mind that if you have any horizontal surfaces like half walls, niches, and benches that those need the Redgard over them.
Hello!
we just had a plastic shower insert removed and hired a contractor to tile. As far as I know, he used Durock on the walls and floor and created a built in shelf as well, then used Mapai uncoupling membrane mortar (just the mortar not the actual membrane) between the Durock and the tiles. According to him this seals everything and prevents any leaks. Should I trust this or should I have it redone?
*The shower floor is tiled, no pan. and a liner wasn’t installed… just the Durock all over.
Hopefully, you haven’t paid this contractor in full yet and I would advise against doing so until you’re able to test the shower, at a minimum. There has to be a liner in the shower or the water flow isn’t managed. And, no, the mortar doesn’t seal everything.
Now if you are in a state like Florida, I know that sometimes they try to tell you that liners aren’t necessary. I’ll admit that the risks aren’t as great as other areas but every shower needs to have the water managed to get down the drain. It’s also a problem if there is no waterproofing on the shower niche. That will rot the wall out over time.
However, it doesn’t sound like this contractor is very skilled and may even be a con artist.
Just got our basement guest shower done and feel the contractor didn’t do it correctly. He put Durock sheet on the base and curb along with coat of red guard. Didn’t even let it dry before putting thinset and tile. The slope is minimal so some water collects around the pebble tiles. I also don’t think he put the drain properly as the contraption with weeping holes is sitting in the box and obviously not installed. My question is would laying epoxy on top of pebble tile help waterproof it?
Not in budget to spend more money right now with a baby on way. This was supposed to be a guest shower for my mom who is going to help with baby. Clearly if issues come up in next few months, we will have to tear up and re do base but reluctant to proceed that way right now. Thanks
I think trying to regrout with an epoxy would be more trouble than it’s worth. At this point, your shower is either waterproof or it isn’t. Any additional coating on top of things isn’t going to make it waterproof. Your best bet is to keep an eye on it and watch for signs of leaks.
The weep hole protector not being installed doesn’t mean that the weep holes are plugged. They may, or may not be, but not installing the protector doesn’t guarantee that they are.
Thank you! Appreciate time and advice.
We recently had a slow leak from the upstairs bathroom that began after we took a shower and did not stop for three days. During these three days we filled up 3 mason jars full of water, along with the water abatement team who put dehumidifiers both in the bathroom upstairs and downstairs in our family room for two of the three days the dripping was happening. The dehumidifiers were pulling moister out and the tubes had water in them which was directed to our bathroom sinks. This was being done until we got the asbestos test back. Then they opened the ceiling and no dripping was found. The wood and dry wall were damp but drying with the dehumidifiers. The pipes seem to be fine both incoming water and the shower and toilet drain with no water leaking when the toilet was flushed or water was put directly down the shower drain. Then a test of water sprayed towards the corner of the 17 year old tiled shower with backer board began to show some water coming down into the floor below. The question I have, could the slow dripping we experienced over 3 days come from the backer board being so saturated with water because a break in the seal of the tile and the backer board dripped the excess water down into the lower floor over the three days & then just stopped? Thanks!
It sounds to me like you have a leaking shower. A shower should function whether there are cracks in grout joints or not. In fact, it should function properly before any tile is installed.
What I’m wondering about is how long you guys have lived with this shower? Because showers don’t usually start leaking. They usually leak from the start. It could be something happened to cause it to start leaking but that’s not the norm, in my experience.
So if you guys are newer owners of this home then the shower may not have been used by the previous homeowners. This happens sometimes. https://www.diytileguy.com/do-not-buy-newly-remodeled-home/
Thank you so much for your commentary and feedback to all of these questions!
We have lived in our house for about 2 years. Our master bath was tiled with glass shower door and bench. Recently water started coming out of kitchen ceiling whcih is below the bathroom after and the entire drywall in the ceiling was soaked. It was first believed to be a drain issue but turns our to have stemmed from a small crack in grout on the edge of the horizontal edge of the bench before it goes vertical.
It turns out that no waterproofing was done behind the tiles. Just cement boards and tiles onto that. Water leaked from bench of shower and also onto the plywood of shower floor as well. Shower had been renovated in ‘07 by previous owners and as far as we know, no issues until now.
Shower floor also had tiles laid directly onto plywood subfloor (nothing between). The shower is being redone as well as the bathroom floor.
We will have another glass shower door installed and the bench stays. The floor is not a pan but a one piece shower floor. Can you tel me, what is best to go between the bathroom floor tiles and also best thing to waterproof the bench to the point it meets the single piece floor? I trust my contractor who seems very knowledgeable in this area, but I never want to have to have our kitchen ceiling opened up again or have a leak like this.
Thank you!
Sorry to hear about the issues but this story is not an unusual one. I can’t say which product or method is “best”. Rather, many products and methods work quite well if they are installed properly.
So, I would work with your contractor to find out which products are available in your area and he/she is comfortable with. Then inform yourself as to how they are to be installed and monitor that they are installed correctly.
Finally, make sure that whichever product/method is used that a flood test is performed! https://www.diytileguy.com/flood-testing-shower/
If all of those things check out then you should be in good shape for years to come.
Our contractor hot-mopped the floor of our shower, flood tested it, and laid the first (of two?) cement over tarred floor when it appeared dry. Tar leaked oil?] up through the cement and cement cracked in places. I put an old towel over the oily tar spots on the floor and, with bare feet, stepped down on them to see if they transferred any oil or tar to the towel when pressed down against it. I did not find any transfer but when I stepped across the towel, my foot went down and I heard a “crunch”. My contractor’s response was (seriously): re the “crunch-bubble”, I should NOT be stepping onto shower floor; re oil seepage, that was not a problem, No, the cement was the first layer; I should not worry about it. I am working with an forensic tile inspector who documented many “wrongs”; my contractor continues to discredit him. (He has 40+ years of experience, etc.) There is much, much more but this is relative to waterproofing (as directed). Thank you in advance for your response.
If you’re working with a forensic inspector, they will have to document everything and compare it to our industry’s written methods and standards. The contractor should be doing the same. So you’ll get resolution on who and what is to blame. I don’t see a question in your comment so I’m not sure if this is helpful or not. Let me know if there is something specific that you would like me to comment on. But you’re consultant is the one that is hands-on and can see everything.
Thanks so much for this response. It’s very helpful.
We have to replace the shower floor as well. Do you think a once piece floor (stone, acrylic, cast iron) or tiled floor is best?
My reply above was assuming that you would replace the shower floor. As far as which kind, it’s more personal preference. Usually, the one-piece are cheaper and easier to install whereas the tile floor would be considered more high end.
Both of the tile wall and tile floor showers in my new home appear to have been built with these layers from the plywood subfloor (used throughout the house) up:
– “Hardiebacker fiber cement with. . . ” — there’s a cut line at this point and I don’t know what the rest of the stamp on the board says.
– And yes, I do mean Hardiebacker on the floor with screws to hold it down. There is a seam on the floor as well with what appears to be white caulk along the seam. The same white material (caulk?) is at all of the edge seams and up the walls in the corners and wall seams.
– The top surface of the Hardiebacker on the floor has what appears to be some type of waterproof coating that has dried mostly clear. I cannot tell if the white caulk was done before or after the clear(ish) waterproofing. This waterproofing layer does not go up the walls. It stops where the edge of the floor meets the wall and that is where there is more white caulk.
– There is no membrane present and I know for certain there is nothing behind the Hardiebacker board on the wall. Insulation comes in direct contact with the back of the Hardiebacker board.
– Then there is a layer of what appears to be cement and provides the general slope to the drain. I don’t believe there is any mesh lath under this because I never saw any scraps.
– The next layer appears to be the thin set, then tile and grout.
The wall boards were installed shortly after the 2×4 wall framing stage and long before any further finish work was started on the shower. I know there is no membrane that goes 12″ up from the floor behind the boards but that seems to be a common recommendation.
Regular wood (stacked 1×4’s it looks like) were used for the curb and they are screwed down. Then more Hardiebacker board on the inside, top (with screws), and outside. My pictures during construction time show no evidence of any kind of sealer or waterproofing on the curb. The curb is then finished with thin set, 6×6 tiles with multiple grout lines, and grout.
I’m an IT guy with zero experience building or remodeling a tile shower. But I know how to search the internet for experienced DIY sites and advice. Everything I’m reading gives me great cause to worry that the long-term integrity of my showers is, well, not very long-term. I feel the only way to have confidence and correct this is to do demolition down to the studs and plywood subfloor and start over. Am I overreacting? Are the layering techniques I’ve described generally acceptable for a good, solid, watertight shower?
Many thanks for your thoughts!
It doesn’t sound like it was built correctly and what your describing about the curb is almost certainly wrong. However, in your situation, you will almost certainly have to have a problem in order for a repair to be done by the builder. Without a problem, it would be difficult to get them to fix anything and would probably require an attorney.
You could do a flood test on it and see if there is any leaking. A leak would qualify as a problem, for sure.
Thanks so much for your quick reply, on a holiday, no less. One new item I’ve learned is that the thin set used under the floor tiles has instructions on the back indicating not for use on shower floors.
That is interesting. Is the thinset from a bucket maybe?
Thanks for all the information you share. It really is invaluable. My husband and I are redoing our shower, and are trying to wrap our heads around all the steps. I’m sure it is fairly straightforward once you’ve done it a time or two…but we haven’t. I apologize if I use incorrect terms in my descriptions; I’m still learning all of this.
So far, our plan is to frame the wood bench and anchor it to the foundation and studs. Frame the floating shelf and anchor it to studs. Lay the shower base slope (putting down a layer of thin set to help deck mud adhere to concrete foundation). Here’s where we are running into the biggest questions. Do we need a pvc shower pan liner, or can we simply coat the shower pan and cement board with Mapei Aquadefence once we put the cement board up? Coating everything seems easier, what with figuring out how to make the bench waterproof and dealing with folding the liner.
Following the shower pan, we would put up the cement board, sealing all the seams and screw holes. Then coat the walls with Aquadefence, and lay the tile.
We have several other questions.
1. Shower will rest on a concrete slab foundation. From what I’ve read, we can use a layer of thin set to help the deck mud base adhere to the foundation. Is this correct?
2. How reinforced do the walls of the shower need to be to hold the weight of the cement board and tile?
3. In several videos, I’ve seen people mention framing the first several inches above the shower pan. I assume this is mostly for making it easier to have the pvc liner reach several inches above the base? Is it necessary to have this framing?
4. If we do use the liner for the shower pan, what keeps it from causing weakness and slippage between the two layers of deck mud? (the slope below and 1.5 inches above)
5. Just to confirm, once the aquadefence is on the walls, we can tile directly onto it, as long as we don’t use pre-mixed thinset?
6. Why does the curb need a wire mesh while the rest of the shower doesn’t?
These are all excellent questions and you are giving me some ideas for future posts on my blog.
To answer your questions, there are different types of showers and they are built differently. The techniques aren’t always compatible between them. So, first, you have to figure out which kind of shower that you want to make and then buy and install the proper drain to go with that system.
In regards to your first unnumbered question, there are two different kinds of drains that are waterproofed in two different ways. One uses a shower pan liner and the other uses a bonded waterproof membrane, such as Aquadefense.
If you have a 3-piece clamping drain installed then you’ll need to use the shower pan liner that clamps into the drain. It sounds like you are leaning towards that type of system. If so, you would only use the AquaDefense on the shower walls, bench, and shelf- but not the shower floor.
For your numbered questions:
1. Yes, this is correct but it should be done as you go so that the thinset is wet when the deck mud contacts it
2. The framing should be 16-inches on-center and everything should be firmly fastened and installed. I don’t know how to describe it unless I use technical deflection numbers which don’t mean anything to most people.
3. This is part of building code and is particularly important if you are installing a shower liner system which is what was first described. This means that you put in 2×6 blocking in between the stud bays around the bottom of the shower where the liner goes.
4. It’s sandwiched in there and has no place to go
5. Correct
6. Wire mesh is used on curbs that get a shower liner. The reason for it is that you are able to build a concrete surface around the curb without puncturing the waterproofing.
With all the above being said, I’d like to offer a bit of advice.
The traditional shower system, with a shower pan liner, is not how I would recommend a DIY’er to build a shower. In fact, a lot of younger pro tilers don’t even know how to build these types of showers.
What I would recommend is, first, a foam shower system like Wedi or Kerdi-board. These are very straightforward but a little costly.
Secondly, I would recommend the Schluter Kerdi system which is a sheet membrane system. This is less expensive but has excellent step-by-step instructions and all the parts to get you set up for success. They even have an adapter for a 3-piece clamping drain if that’s what you have installed. There’s no worrying about lath (wire mesh) for the curb. Additionally, you can do a mortar bed shower pan if you have a non-standard shower.
Schluter Kerdi system
https://www.diytileguy.com/shower-waterproofing/
Thanks for your input! It helped clear some things up as well as paving the way for more questions…
For some reason when reading through all the waterproofing methods, I didn’t understand that using a liquid membrane on walls and floor (without the liner) was an acceptable method. If we go this route, what kind of drain should we use? (Mapei suggests pretreating the drain with aquadefence to help seal it, but I’m not sure if that means we can make any drain work.) We currently have an “Oatey 6-inch square holes square shower drain”. Looks like it is a clamping drain, so according to what you said, it wouldn’t be compatible.
Also, the original drain was in a hole about a square foot wide filled with sand. Should we fill that and let it set before laying the shower pan or just fill it as we create the pan?
If we use the aquadefence system, do we still need to use the mesh on the curb? Or simply coat the wood and then tile over it?
You can use your existing drain as-is and do what’s know as the “divot method”. I’ve been trying to find a specific link for this but can’t find what I’m looking for. However, I think your best bet would be to order in a Kerdi drain with a clamping drain adapter or use the new FloFX drain.
I would fill the hole with concrete before starting your mud pan and use the mesh on the curb. FYI, the curb should be wrapped in backer board with the seams filled with thinset and mesh tape before waterproofing.
Finally, I’m not crazy about using water-based waterproofers for shower pans. I would order in Mapei Mapelastic Turbo for waterproofing the shower floor, curb, and about 6-inches up the walls. Then use AquaDefense on the walls, bench, and shelf.
Make sure that you flood test it: https://www.diytileguy.com/flood-testing-shower/
How much concrete would you recommend to fill the hole? Just a few inches on top, or should we cement the entire drain system in? Also, how long do we need to wait for that to dry before laying the shower pan?
What is the difference between the Mapelastic Turbo and AquaDefense? I’m not able to find a lot of information on it, or even how to get it!
What are the disadvantages to using the liquid waterproofers for shower pans (I’m just assuming that all the main liquid waterproofers are water-based)?
You should be fine with just a couple of inches of concrete. Then the shower pan material can go over that once it’s dry.
Mapelastic Turbo is a two-part mixture that is going to be a better grade than AquaDefense. Turbo is a newer product so it might be more difficult to locate.
The problem with liquid waterproofers, such as AquaDefense, Redgard, and Hydroban, are that they are finicky to apply. They have to be a certain thickness, dry completely between coats, and can have issues once they are flood tested. I’ve had them bubble up once water has been added. Additionally, the thickness usually isn’t simple to achieve as they typically need to be “credit card thick.”
So, I’d rather see people use the non water-based version, such as the urethane-based Redgard Speedcoat and Hydroban Quck Cure. Or the two-part products like Mapelastic Turbo and Ardex 8+9.
I just think they are more predictable once they are applied. That being said, AquaDefense is rated for shower pans and it is possible to successfully install it in that situation.
One more thing: AquaDefense, Redgard, and Hydroban need a completely cured mortar bed, which is 72 hours minimum, before being applied. Other waterproofing products don’t need to wait that long.
You mentioned in previous post that Redgard Speed Coat or Hydroban Quick Cure would be better than the standard AquaDefense, Redgard, Hydroban because they are less finicky to apply. Since the first two cost a lot more than the 2nd three, which of the last three do you recommend?
…for shower walls.
Of the water-based ones I prefer Hydroban. The color and it just seems to go on smoother than the others. Although AquaDefense has now changed their color to a lighter tone which is much better both for writing on it and overall mood when working in it